Military Wiki

The United States Department of Defense (DOD) had stopped reporting Guantanamo suicide attempts in 2002. In mid-2002 the DoD changed the way they classified suicide attempts, and enumerated them under other acts of "self-injurious behavior". On January 24, 2005 the U.S. military revealed that in 2003, there were 350 incidents of "self-harm."[1] 120 of those incidents of self-harm were attempts by detainees to hang themselves. Twenty-three detainees participated in a mass-suicide attempt from August 18 to 26, 2003.[1] A number of incidents happened after a change in command at the camp in 2003 increased the severity of interrogation techniques used by military and CIA intelligence officers.[1]

On June 10, 2006, the DOD announced that three prisoners held by the United States at the Guantanamo Bay detainment camps had committed suicide. The June 10, 2006 suicides were the first inmate deaths at the Guantanamo Bay detainment camp.[2] The DoD acknowledged there had been a total of 41 suicide attempts among 29 detainees until that date.[2] Since June 2006, DOD has announced three suicide deaths by detainees at Guantanamo. In 2008, the NCIS released a heavily redacted report of its investigation of the three suicides at Guantanamo in 2006.

In reports published in 2009 and 2010, Seton Hall University Law School's Center for Policy and Research and a joint investigation by Harper's magazine and NBC News, respectively, strongly criticized the government's account of the 2006 suicides. Harper's 2010 article, based on accounts by four former Guantanamo guards, asserted that DOD had initiated a cover-up of deaths resulting from torture during interrogation. The DOD has denied these allegations.

History: Conditions of detainees

In 2002 the United States government kept conditions at Guantanamo extremely secret, not releasing information about the detainees and especially not their names. That year, the United States Department of Defense (DOD) stopped reporting suicide attempts at the camps. In mid-2002 the DOD changed the way they classified suicide attempts, referring to these acts as "self-injurious behavior", one of many euphemisms the Bush administration coined to shield the facts of camp events. Medical experts outside the camp have argued that doctors did not have sufficient understanding of the detainees to make such conclusions about their intentions or motives. In the spring of 2003, 32 Afghans and three Pakistanis were released from the detention camp. News media reported from interviews with them that some former detainees described despair and numerous attempts among prisoners to commit suicide, in large part because of individuals' belief in their innocence, the harshness of camp conditions, and especially the indefinite confinement and unending uncertainty they faced.[3]

Quotes from ex-detainees:

"I was trying to kill myself", said Shah Muhammad, 20, a Pakistani who was captured in northern Afghanistan in November 2001, turned over to American soldiers and flown to Guantánamo in January 2002. "I tried four times, because I was disgusted with my life."
"We needed more blankets, but they would not listen", he said.[3] The U.S. government denied claims of prisoner abuse at the time, but on May 9, 2004, The Washington Post publicized classified documents that showed the Pentagon had approved interrogation techniques at Guantánamo including sleep deprivation, and exposure to extreme hot and cold, bright lights without relief, and loud music.[4]

On January 24, 2005 the U.S. military revealed that in 2003, there were 350 incidents of "self-harm" among detainees at Guantanamo.[1] 120 of those incidents were attempts by detainees to hang themselves. From August 18 to 26, 2003, twenty-three detainees participated in a mass-suicide attempt.[1] Reporters noted that numerous attempted suicides occurred after a change in command at the camp resulted in an increase in the severity of interrogation techniques used against the detainees.[1]

Reported suicides on June 10, 2006

On June 10, 2006 the DOD announced that three detainees had died at Guantanamo, saying they "killed themselves in an apparent suicide pact".[5] The prisoners were the Saudi Arabians Mani al-Utaybi and Yasser al-Zahrani, and a Yemeni citizen, Ali Abdullah Ahmed.[6]

The prison commander Rear Admiral Harry Harris, Jr. (2006-2007) stated: "This was not an act of desperation, but an act of asymmetric warfare committed against us." [7] Harris also said that the Guantanamo detainees were: "dangerous, committed to killing Americans.".[8] He claimed that there was a myth among the detainees that if three detainees were known to have died in the camps, the DOD would be pressured to send the rest of the detainees home.

President George Bush expressed "serious concern."[2] Colleen Graffy, the Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Public Diplomacy, called the suicides, "a good PR move"—and, "a tactic to further the jihadi cause".[9]

On June 12, 2006, Cully Stimson, the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Detainee Affairs, said:

"I wouldn't characterize it as a good PR move. What I would say is that we are always concerned when someone takes his own life, because as Americans, we value life, even the lives of violent terrorists who are captured waging war against our country."[10]

The Scotsman characterized this as an attempt by the Bush administration "... to pull back from the earlier comments about public relations and 'asymmetric warfare'."[10]

Sean McCormack, spokesman for the United States State Department, said, "I would not say that it was a PR stunt".[11] He said that the detainees were apparently unaware that one of them was due to be transferred to Saudi Arabia, under terms that would require him to be kept in custody, and another was to be released to Saudi Arabia.[11] Joshua Denbeaux, a lawyer representing detainees through the Center for Constitutional Rights, has said that prison authorities were withholding this information because US officials had not decided which country the detainee was going to be transferred to.[11] Denbeaux is one of the principal authors of A Profile of 517 Detainees through Analysis of Department of Defense Data (2006), published by the Center for Policy and Analysis of Seton Hall University Law School. It analyzed DOD data about the prisoners' identities and allegations for why they were being detained.[11]

Colonel Michael Bumgarner (April 2005- June 2006), the commander of the camp's guard force, reacted to the suicides by telling his officers soon afterward: "The trust level is gone. They have shown time and time again that we can't trust them any farther than we can throw them. There is not a trustworthy son of a ... in the entire bunch."[12]

Skepticism about suicide claims

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer reported that news of the deaths raised skepticism over whether the Saudi men had committed suicide.[13] The article reports Saudi government and family speculation that the men were driven to suicide by torture. Several prominent Saudis accused the camp authorities of murdering the three men. The Seattle PI reported:

"Some people in the conservative Islamic kingdom questioned whether Muslim men would kill themselves since suicide is a grave sin in Islam. But defense lawyers and some former detainees said many prisoners at Guantanamo are wasting away in deep despair at their long captivity."[13]

Kateb al Shimri, a Saudi lawyer representing the Saudi prisoners, said: "The families don't believe it, and of course I don't believe it either. A crime was committed here and the U.S. authorities are responsible."[13]

Joshua Denbeaux of the Center for Constitutional Rights said that the suicides: "...represent the Pentagon's absolute worst nightmare."[14] Denbeaux added: "...many of these prisoners have been trying to kill themselves, for months, if not years."[14]

Senator Arlen Specter, chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, commented: "Where we have evidence, they ought to be tried, and if convicted, they ought to be sentenced."[8] Specter added that many of the prisoners' captures were based on: "...the flimsiest sort of hearsay."[8]

Government comments/investigation

Admiral Harris was quoted as saying: "I think it is less about the length of their detention ... It's less about that and it's more that they continue to fight their fight, I think the vast majority of detainees are resisting us."[15][16]

On July 9, 2006 The Jurist reported that DOD spokesmen have claimed that the dead men received assistance from others.[17][18][19] Further, the DOD claims that preparations for the hangings were written on the blank paper issued to the detainees' lawyers. As part of the investigation by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS), the camp authorities seized almost all the documents from almost all the detainees, a total of half a ton of papers, including their privileged, confidential communications with their lawyers.[17] The administration wants to suspend all lawyers' visits, while a commission reviews the papers for any sign that the detainees' lawyers helped plan the suicides.[19] (Note: The NCIS heavily redacted report was released publicly in August 2008.)

Lawyers for Guantanamo detainees reported that the camp authorities were confiscating detainees' mail and legal papers.[20] The lawyers report that at least one of their clients attributes the confiscation to DOD thinking they might suggest that the suicides were planned, and possibly encouraged, by detainees' lawyers. According to Clive Stafford Smith, legal director of Reprieve, a British organization representing numerous detainees: "They think that they are going to find letters from us suggesting suicide. It's ludicrous."[20]

Comments by released detainees who knew the dead men

Bahraini detainee Abdulla Majid Al Naimi, who was released on November 8, 2005 said he knew the three dead men.[21] Al Naimi said that Al-Utaybi and Ahmed were captured while studying in Pakistan. He said that they were interrogated for only a brief time after their arrival in Guantanamo. Their interrogators had told them they were not regarded as a threat, and that they could expect to be released.

"The interrogations dealt with them only during the first month of their detention. For more than a year before I left Guantanamo in November 2005, they were left alone. But they were still held in bad conditions in the camp by the guards."

Al Naimi said that Al Zahrani was only 16 when he was captured. Al Naimi thought he should have been treated as a minor.[21]

"He was 21 when he died, barely the legal age in most countries, and was merely 16 when he was picked up four and half years ago. His age shows that he is not even supposed to be taken to a police office; he should have been turned over to the underage [juvenile] authorities."

Allegations of homicide and cover-up

Guantanamo Bay murder accusations were made by United States sources in December 2009 and January 2010 regarding the deaths of three Guantanamo prisoners in June 2006 at the United States Guantanamo Bay detention camp for enemy combatants at its naval base in Cuba. Two of the men had been cleared by the military for release. The United States Department of Defense claimed their deaths at the time as suicides, although their families and the Saudi government argued against the findings. The DOD undertook an investigation by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service.

Following release of the redacted NCIS investigative report in 2008, Seton Hall University Law School's Center for Policy and Research published Death in Camp Delta (2009), a report criticizing the NCIS account for inconsistencies and weaknesses. The Center concluded that there was serious negligence at the camp, or there may have been cover-up of homicides resulting from torture. It noted that no military personnel had been prosecuted for any failings related to the deaths of the detainees.[22]

In 2010, Harper's Weekly and NBC News released the report of a joint investigation, based on accounts by four former Military Intelligence staff, stationed at the time at Guantanamo. The article written by Scott Horton, a journalist and human rights attorney, suggested the military under the Bush administration had covered up deaths of the detainees that occurred under torture at a "black site" in the course of interrogations.[23] In 2011, Horton's article on the Guantanamo events won the National Magazine Awards for Reporting.[24] The award revived a round of criticism of the article's veracity.[25][26]

Attorneys' concerns

In 2006 and later, defense attorneys were concerned about their clients' mental health. Mark Denbeaux is a law professor at Seton Hall University and director of its Center for Policy and Research, which had published numerous reports on conditions at Guantanamo. He represents two Tunisian detainees and said at the time that he was worried that other detainees were candidates for suicide.[27]

In 2008 the Canadian Supreme Court ordered the release of a video of a February 2003 interrogation conducted by the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) and a Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) officer of Omar Khadr, a Canadian citizen who was 15 years old when captured and one of the youngest detainees held at Guantánamo. In the video, the 16-year-old Khadr repeatedly cried, saying what sounds to be either "help me", "kill me," or calling for his mother, in Urdu (Pakistani).[28][29][30] The government was reviewing CSIS actions in its interrogations of Canadian citizens at Guantanamo, including the minor Khadr, as more information had been revealed about abuse of detainees prior to interrogations.[31] Khadr was finally scheduled to be tried at Guantanamo in 2010. He pleaded guilty in a plea bargain, served a year of his sentence there, and in 2012 was returned to Canada to serve the rest of his sentence.

Fourth suicide, May 30, 2007

The Southern Command announced on the evening of May 30, 2007 that a Saudi prisoner had died of suicide.[32][33] They announced: "The detainee was found unresponsive and not breathing in his cell by guards." The DoD did not immediately release the dead man's identity. The DoD asserted that his body would be treated with cultural sensitivity.

The statement closed with the following:[32][33]

"The mission of detention and interrogation at Guantanamo continues. This mission is vital to the security of our nation and our allies and is being carried out professionally and humanely by the men and women of Joint Task Force Guantanamo."

On May 31, 2007 Saudi officials announced that the dead man was Abdul Rahman Maadha al-Amry.[34] The Associated Press reported that same day that al-Amry had been identified as one of the "high-value detainees", held in Camp 5.[35][36] Carol Rosenberg of the Miami Herald reported his name as Abdul Rahman Ma Ath Thafir Al Amri and that he was a military veteran of the Saudi army.[37] He had never been allowed to meet with an attorney.[37] Other newspaper reports commented on the timing of the death, pointing out that it was almost a year after the three deaths of June 10, 2006. They noted that both incidents followed a new commander being assigned to JTF-GTMO. In addition, the deaths had occurred before the convening of a military commission to judge detainees' cases.[38][39]

Fifth suicide June 1, 2009

Mohammad Ahmed Abdullah Saleh Al Hanashi, a 31-year-old prisoner from Yemen, died in the camps on June 1, 2009. On June 2, 2009 the DOD reported that he committed suicide.[40] [41] A number of journalists were at the camp to cover a military commission for Omar Khadr, a Canadian citizen who is the youngest detainee and the last western citizen to be held there. (Note: He was returned to Canada in 2012 after a plea bargain, to continue serving his sentence.) The camp authorities did not allow journalists to report news of Al Hanashi's death until after they had left Guantanamo.[41]

Sixth suicide May 18, 2011

DOD announced that Inayatullah, 37, an Afghan detainee held since 2007 on suspicion of being a member of Al Qaeda, was found dead on May 18, an apparent suicide.[42] The press reported that his given name is Hajji Nassim, according to his attorney.[43] He was referred to as Inayatullah only at the Guantanamo camp. He was arrested in Iran near the border with Afghanistan, and was classified by DOD as an "indefinite detainee."[43]

Reported suicide attempts

Juma Al Dossary
  • Made at least 13 suicide attempts.
  • Attempted suicide during a lawyer's visit.[44]
  • Repatriated to Saudi Arabia, where he graduated from the Saudi jihadist rehabilitation program.
Mishal Awad Sayaf Alhabiri
  • Left brain-damaged, allegedly following a failed suicide attempt. He can still obey simple instructions.[45]
  • Repatriated to Saudi custody.
Sha Mohammed Alikhel
  • Sent to the punishment cells when Guantanamo was full, and all the ordinary cells were occupied.[46]
  • Reports detention in the punishment cells drove him to despair and he made four suicide attempts.
  • Released May 8, 2003.
mass suicide bid
  • Late 2003 - 23 detainees tried to hang themselves simultaneously.[47]
Isa Khan
  • Khan has been released in Pakistan but is under surveillance. He reports that enduring constant surveillance, when he knows he is innocent feels intolerable. He has considered suicide since his release.[48]
Muhammad Saad Iqbal
  • Muhammad Saad Iqbal told his CSRT that he had to wear the orange jumpsuit of the non-compliant captive because he attempted suicide on the 191st day of his detention.[49]
Seven Saudi detainees
  • Joshe Natreen, the American lawyer of seven Saudi detainees, reported in July 2006 that a Guantanamo official told her that another Saudi had attempted suicide since June 10, 2006.[50]
  • On December 5, 2007 an unidentified detainee was taken to the prison hospital, and required stitches, after he tried to cut his throat.[51]
Allal Ab Aljallil Abd Al Rahman Abd
  • Slit his wrist during an interview with David Remes, his lawyer, in mid-2009.[52]
  • Previous suicide attempts had resulted in his being confined to the facility's psychiatric ward.[52]

See also

  • Prisoner suicide
  • Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi—a detainee who was tortured while in CIA custody, who was reported to have committed suicide after being repatriated to Libyan custody.


  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 23 Detainees Attempted Suicide in Protest at Base, Military Says, Associated Press, January 25, 2005 Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "Nytimes050125" defined multiple times with different content
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 Three detainees kill themselves at Guantanamo, Reuters, June 11, 2006
  3. 3.0 3.1 Gall, Carlotta; Lewis, Neil A. (June 17, 2003). "Threats And Responses: Captives; Tales Of Despair From Guantánamo". The New York Times. Retrieved May 4, 2010. 
  4. Dana Priest and Joe Stephens. "Pentagon Approved Tougher Interrogations". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 2013-02-10. Retrieved 2006-12-28. 
  5. Triple suicide at Guantanamo camp, BBC, June 11, 2006
  6. Three Guantanamo detainees die in suicides, Reuters, June 10, 2006
  7. "Three die in Guantanamo suicide pact", The Times, June 11, 2006
  8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 "Suicides spur Guantanamo criticism", CNN, June 11, 2006
  9. "Guantanamo suicides a 'PR move'", BBC, 11 June 2006
  10. 10.0 10.1 "Guantanamo inmate killed himself 'unaware he was due to be freed'", The Scotsman, June 13, 2006
  11. 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 "Guantanamo suicides 'not PR move'". BBC. 12 June 2006. 
  12. "Guards tighten security to prevent more deaths: Human rights groups, defense lawyers call for investigation of 3 men's suicides in military prison", Charlotte Observer, June 13, 2006
  13. 13.0 13.1 13.2 "Saudis allege torture in Guantanamo deaths", Seattle Post-Intelligencer, June 11, 2006
  14. 14.0 14.1 Christie, Michael (June 11, 2006). "Three suicides reported at Guantanamo Bay". Retrieved October 2, 2011. 
  15. "Official: Gitmo Prisoners Waging 'Jihad'", Associated Press, June 28, 2006
  16. "Guantanamo Bay suicide prisoners 'showed no sign of being depressed'", The Independent, June 28, 2006
  17. 17.0 17.1 "DOJ tells court legal notes may have aided Guantanamo suicide plot", The Jurist, July 9, 2006
  18. "Guantanamo Probe Finds Evidence of Plot", Associated Press, July 9, 2006
  19. 19.0 19.1 "U.S. Says Inmate Legal Notes May Have Aided Suicide Plot", New York Times, July 9, 2006
  20. 20.0 20.1 "Guantanamo lawyers say letters seized", San Jose Mercury, June 30, 2006
  21. 21.0 21.1 Ex-detainee disputes triple suicide report, Gulf Daily News, June 25, 2006
  22. "SETON HALL LAW RELEASES LATEST GTMO REPORT, "DEATH IN CAMP DELTA"". Seton Hall University School of Law (press release). 2009-12-07. 
  23. Horton, Scott (2010-01-18). "The Guantánamo "Suicides": A Camp Delta sergeant blows the whistle". Harper's magazine. 
  24. Foreign Policy: Six Questions for Scott Horton.
  25. Adweek: The National Magazine Award and Guantánamo: A Tall Tale Gets the Prize.
  26. Time: Flaws Exposed in Guantanamo Article that Won Magazine Award.
  27. "Detainees Commit Suicide in Protest at Guantanamo". Fox News Channel. 2006-06-11.,2933,199013,00.html. Retrieved 2010-02-28. "Denbeaux said one of his clients, Mohammed Abdul Rahman, appeared to be depressed and hardly spoke during a June 1 visit. Rahman was on a hunger strike at the time and was force-fed soon after, Denbeaux said. 'He told us he would rather die than stay in Guantánamo,' the attorney said. 'He doesn't believe he will ever get out of Guantánamo alive.'" 
  28. "What exactly did Omar Khadr say? 'Help me,' 'kill me'? (UPDATED 7 p.m. ET)". National Post. 2008-07-15. Retrieved 2008-07-25. "[The audio appears to be Mr. Khadr saying 'Kill me' repeatedly as well as saying 'Help me' occasionally. A native Arabic speaker told Reuters that he believed he was saying 'Ya ummi' meaning, 'My mother.'"  mirror
  29. Colin Freeze, Katherine O'Neill (2008-07-16). "Omar Khadr: The interrogation". The Globe and Mail. Toronto. Archived from the original on 2008-07-18. Retrieved 2008-07-25. "The most widely circulated footage showed Mr. Khadr breaking down in a room by himself, repeatedly saying something that sounded like "kill me, or ya ummi [Oh Mom]," after ripping off his orange jumpsuit." 
  30. Colin Perkel (2008-07-16). "Interrogation video shows sobbing Omar Khadr". Kitchener-Waterloo Record. Retrieved 2008-07-25. "Later in the tape, a distraught Khadr is seen rocking, his face in his hands. 'Help me,' he sobs repeatedly. He also appears to say 'Kill me.'" 
  31. "CSIS failed in Khadr case, review finds", Toronto Star, Jul 16 2009, accessed 9 February 2013
  32. 32.0 32.1 Jane Sutton (May 30, 2007). "Saudi prisoner kills self at Guantanamo, U.S. says". Reuters. Retrieved 2007-05-30. [dead link]
  33. 33.0 33.1 "Detainee death at Guantanamo". Department of Defense. May 30, 2007. Retrieved May 30, 2007. 
  34. Michael Melia (May 31, 2007). "Saudi Arabian Guantanamo detainee dies in apparent suicide". San Diego Union Tribune. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  35. "U.S.: Dead Detainee Was of High Value". Central Florida News. May 31, 2007. Archived from the original on 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  36. "U.S.: Guantanamo Suicide Was "High-Value" Inmate". Stratfor. May 31, 2007. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  37. 37.0 37.1 Carol Rosenberg (May 31, 2007). "Dead Gitmo captive was Saudi military veteran". Miami Herald. Retrieved 2007-05-31. [dead link]
  38. Michael Melia (May 31, 2007). "U.S.: Dead Detainee Was of High Value". Casper Star Tribune. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  39. "Saudi Arabian Guantanamo detainee dies in apparent suicide". Boston Herald. May 31, 2007. Archived from the original on 2007-09-29. Retrieved 2007-05-31. 
  40. David McFadden, Danica Coto (2009-06-02). "Military: Gitmo detainee dies of apparent suicide". Associated Press. Archived from the original on 2009-06-02. 
  41. 41.0 41.1 "Yemeni Detainee Dies In Apparent Suicide". The Washington Post. June 3, 2009. Retrieved June 27, 2009. 
  42. Gray, Kevin (May 19, 2011). "Afghan prisoner at Guantanamo dies in apparent suicide". Reuters. 
  43. 43.0 43.1 Carol Rosenberg, "Latest Guantánamo prison camp suicide was 'indefinite detainee'", Miami Herald, at McClatchy website, 28 June 2011, accessed 3 January 2013, mirror
  44. Guantanamo Desperation Seen in Suicide Attempts: One Incident Was During Lawyer's Visit, Washington Post, October 31, 2005
  45. Guantanamo Bay documents reveal Taliban's allure, Taipei Times, March 6, 2006
  46. Inmates Released from Guantanamo Tell Tales of Despair, New York Times, June 17, 2003
  47. "Kicked out of Gitmo: A Times reporter's struggle to get the truth about America's island prison just got tougher", Los Angeles Times, June 18, 2006
  48. "Former Guantanamo Bay detainees find that life doesn't get any easier". Taipei Times. January 5, 2006. Retrieved January 7, 2007. 
  49. Summarized transcripts (.pdf) from Muhammad Saad Iqbal's Combatant Status Review Tribunal (CSRT)], p. 55
  50. 3rd Saudi tries to end life at Guantanamo, United Press International, July 5, 2006
  51. "'Fingernail slash' at Guantanamo". BBC. 5 December 2007. Retrieved 2007-12-05. 
  52. 52.0 52.1 Ben Fox (2009-05-11). "Lawyer: Gitmo prisoner slashed wrist, hurled blood". Associated Press. Archived from the original on 2009-05-11. 

External links

5 June 2010

This page uses Creative Commons Licensed content from Wikipedia (view authors).